If you've ever received an online order in a lightweight plastic envelope, you've encountered a poly mailer. These sleek, flexible packages have become the go-to choice for ecommerce shipping over the years. They're durable, weather-resistant, and take up minimal space. With the use of these mailers, one question keeps coming up: are poly mailers recyclable?
The answer is often yes, but it depends on the type of mailer and how it's made. Many thin-film poly mailers can be recycled through store drop-off programs. Others cannot. What's surprising is that two mailers that look identical on the outside can behave completely differently when it comes to disposal.
This guide breaks down everything you need to know so you can understand what you're dealing with and make informed decisions about the packaging you receive or choose for your business.
Quick Answer: Can You Recycle Poly Mailers?
Most poly mailers CAN be recycled, but not in your curbside bin. Single-layer polyethylene mailers (the most common type) are accepted at store drop-off recycling locations alongside plastic grocery bags and other flexible films. Multi-layer mailers and those with special coatings typically cannot be recycled. The key is knowing which type you have and where to take it.
What Poly Mailers Are Made Of
Most poly mailers used for shipping are made from polyethylene, a type of plastic commonly labeled as #2 (high-density polyethylene or HDPE) or #4 (low-density polyethylene or LDPE). These are the same plastics used in grocery bags, dry cleaning bags, and bread bags.
Even though polyethylene film can be recycled, it usually cannot go in your home recycling bin. Flexible plastics get tangled in the sorting machinery at most recycling facilities, which is why curbside programs don't accept them. Instead, these materials need to go to participating store drop-off locations specifically designed to handle plastic films.
Understanding this difference is essential. A mailer can be recyclable, but only if it enters the correct recycling stream.
Types of Poly Mailers and Their Recyclability
Not all poly mailers are created equal. Here's how different types stack up when it comes to recycling:
Recyclable Options: Single-Layer Polyethylene Mailers
Standard LDPE Poly Mailers: These are the most straightforward to recycle. When a poly mailer is made from a single layer of LDPE with no coatings, laminates, or mixed materials, it's generally accepted at store drop-off programs that collect plastic bags and films. The mailer needs to be clean and dry, and while removing shipping labels is helpful, many programs can handle standard labels without issue.
Recycled LDPE Poly Mailers: These mailers made from recycled LDPE work exactly the same way as those made from new plastic. They still qualify for store drop-off recycling if they're clean and meet program guidelines. Choosing recycled content reduces the need for virgin plastic and keeps materials in use instead of sending them to landfills.
Ocean Bound Poly Mailers: Ocean bound plastic refers to plastic collected from coastal areas where it's at risk of entering the ocean. Once collected, it's processed into recycled polyethylene resin. When this material is used to make thin-film mailers, the result is still polyethylene and can typically be recycled through the same store drop-off programs that accept #2 and #4 plastic films. These mailers support coastal cleanup efforts while maintaining established recycling pathways.
Non-Recyclable or Limited Recyclability Options
Multi-Layer Thin-Film Mailers: Some poly mailers appear to be simple film but are actually made from multiple layers bonded together. These layers might include different types of plastics or coatings added for extra strength. The problem is that multi-layer films are much harder to recycle. Most film recycling systems are designed for single-type materials, and laminated structures cannot be easily separated. As a result, many multi-layer mailers are not accepted in recycling streams.
If a mailer feels unusually rigid, glossy, or makes a crinkly sound, it may have a multi-layer construction that affects recyclability.
Compostable Thin-Film Mailers: Compostable mailers are made from plant-based materials rather than polyethylene. They are not recyclable in polyethylene recycling systems and should never be placed in film recycling drop-offs. Most certified compostable mailers require access to industrial composting facilities to break down properly, as certain compostable mailers will not break down in home composting environments. While these mailers offer an alternative for those prioritizing plant-based materials, they must still be disposed of correctly to avoid contaminating recycling streams.
How to Tell If Your Poly Mailer Is Recyclable
Despite variations in local recycling programs, there are reliable ways to determine whether your poly mailer can be recycled.
Look for Resin Codes #2 or #4 - These codes indicate that the mailer is made from HDPE or LDPE, which are the primary plastics accepted at many store drop-off programs. You'll usually find these numbers inside a triangle symbol, often printed on the mailer itself.
Check for Film Recycling Instructions - Some mailers include a symbol or text stating they should be recycled at plastic bag drop-off locations. This is one of the clearest indicators of compatibility with film recycling programs.
Assess the Construction - Single-layer films are more likely to be recyclable than laminated or multi-material films. If the mailer has unusual coatings, a metallic appearance, or feels structurally complex, it may not be recyclable.
Never Assume Curbside Acceptance - Most curbside programs do not accept flexible film plastics. Unless your local program explicitly states otherwise, poly mailers need to go to store drop-off recycling, not your home bin.
Common Misconceptions About Recycling Poly Mailers
"All thin-film mailers can be recycled" - Not true. Multi-layer films and mailers with specialty coatings often cannot be processed in film recycling streams.
"If a mailer is made from recycled content, it can't be recycled again" - False. Recycled polyethylene is still polyethylene. As long as it meets program requirements, it can enter thin-film recycling again.
"Compostable means recyclable" - These are completely different systems. Compostable films cannot be processed with LDPE or HDPE films and will contaminate recycling streams if mixed in.
"All plastics go in the recycling bin" - Many people assume this, but it's rarely correct for flexible films. Clear disposal instructions make a significant difference in whether materials actually get recycled.
What Should You Do With Poly Mailers?
When you receive a package in a poly mailer, here's how to handle it:
-
Check the recycling symbol – Look for resin codes #2 or #4, or text indicating "recycle with plastic bags"
-
Keep it clean and dry – Mailers with excessive dirt or moisture may not be accepted
-
Remove paper inserts – Take out any packing slips or promotional materials
-
Locate a drop-off site – Find participating retailers near you (many grocery stores and big-box retailers have collection bins near the entrance)
-
When in doubt, check – If you're unsure about a mailer's recyclability, contact your local program or check resources like How2Recycle for guidance
Which Poly Mailer Option Is Most Sustainable?
The current recycling system we use today wasn't designed for modern ecommerce packaging, which is why this can feel complicated. There's no universal answer to which poly mailer is "best", since this depends on material composition, what disposal options are available in your area, and your personal priorities.
Recycled LDPE Mailers are strong, moisture-resistant, and compatible with store drop-off recycling. They reduce virgin plastic use and support a circular system.
Ocean Bound Poly Mailers provide the same functional benefits as standard LDPE mailers while supporting global coastal cleanup efforts. They can typically be recycled through the same thin-film programs.
Compostable Mailers work well for those committed to plant-based materials and who have access to industrial composting facilities. They perform differently from polyethylene but offer an alternative disposal pathway.
Paper or Kraft Mailers aren't poly mailers, but many people compare them when evaluating packaging options. Paper is often accepted in curbside recycling, though it offers different performance characteristics and may not protect all products equally well in regards to durability and water resistance.
In short, the most sustainable choice depends on what aligns with your values and what disposal pathways you realistically have access to.
Final Thoughts
Different mailers require different disposal methods, and it is important to know if and how your mailers can be recycled. Next time you receive a mailer, keep the following in mind before tossing it in your home recycling bin:
-
Single-layer polyethylene films should go to store drop-down programs.
-
Ocean-bound or recycled content mailers can also go to store drop-off programs.
-
Multi-layer films usually aren't recyclable, and users should double check before recycling.
-
While kraft and compostable films are not technically used in traditional poly mailers, they are oftentimes used in other mailers and have different disposal protocols that need to be followed.
Clear, accurate information helps everyone make better packaging decisions, whether you're choosing mailers for your business or figuring out how to dispose of the ones that you receive, Understanding your options matter.